Legislation proposed in Illinois that would directly impact the use of social networking sites by teens.
The Synopsis As Introduced:
Creates the Social Networking Website Access Restriction Act.
Provides that an owner of a social networking website must obtain and maintain in a database the written permission of the parent or guardian of each minor who is allowed access to the social networking website.
Provides that an owner of a social networking website must give each parent or guardian unlimited access to the webpage profile of the minor under his or her supervision.
Provides that an owner of a social networking website must implement procedures for verification of the age and information of anyone having a webpage on the social networking website.
Provides that an owner of a social networking website must also verify the status of the parents or guardians who have granted permission to a minor to host a social networking website.
Prohibits registered sex offenders from hosting or accessing a social networking website.
Provides that operators of a social networking website must allow the parent or guardian of the minor unrestricted access to the profile webpage of the minor at all times.
Amends the Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act. Provides that a knowing violation by an owner or operator of the Social Networking Website Access Restriction Act is an unlawful practice within the meaning of the Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act.
These resources can help students investigate:
- The reasons behind this legislation and the legitimacy of the those reasons.
- The viability of the age and identity verification of minors.
- The concerns associated with age and identify verification approaches.
- Strategies teens might use to avoid such restrictions and the possible negative impact of those strategies.
- Strategies teens use to protect themselves on social networking sites.
Representative Tom Cross has introduced this legislation. He is the House Republican Leader.
What are his reasons for introducing this legislation? How valid are those reasons? You can call or email the representative to ask for his reasons. Also look for the names of representatives who have signed on as co-sponsors. What are their reasons for supporting this legislation? Are any of these elected representatives in your district?
It is likely that Rep. Cross will respond that he has concerns about online sexual predators on social networking sites. Rep Cross might raise concerns about the fact that MySpace has removed 90,000 registered sex offenders from the site. He might also raise concerns about cyberbullying.
The Crimes Against Children Research Center has research resources you can consult for more insight into the problem of online sexual predators and cyberbullying:
Read this article to find an important fact about the 90,000 registered sex offenders (hint: last paragraph).
Age and Identity Verification
MySpace entered into an agreement with the state attorneys general to set up a task force to investigate the effectiveness of age and identity verification to protect minors online. The Berkman Internet Safety Technical Task Force was formed to do this. The Berkman Task Force released a report in January 2009.
This blog provides excellent analysis of the Berkman Task Force report and links to many other comments:
Here is a letter that has already been sent to Rep. Cross about this legislation by the American Electronics Association. Are the statements made in this letter accurate?
Questions to Ask
How would social networking sites be able to establish the age and identity of Illinois youth?
How would social networking sites be able to verify which adults have custody of which minors in Illinois?
How effective do you think requirement would be? Can you describe two ways that teens could easily bypass this requirement?
What strategies do you think parents should use to protect children and teens online?
What strategies do teens use to protect themselves on social networking sites?